Dr James M. Hatch, EdD
  • Dr James M. Hatch EdD
  • Who We Are
  • Get In Touch
  • Dr James M. Hatch EdD
  • Who We Are
  • Get In Touch
                  Musings on Japanese and Ryukyu Budo                                 ​

Categories

All
Budo History
International Education
Japanese Culture
Random Thoughts

Mirror-tocracy: Why Organisations Often Recruit Their Own Decline

25/7/2026

 
Picture
"The greatest danger to any organisation is not that it lacks talent, but that it gradually loses the capacity to recognise talent that does not resemble itself."

There are occasions in one's academic life when a seemingly innocuous conversation fundamentally alters the way one understands a familiar phenomenon. Such was the case during a recent discussion with my long-time friend and fellow educational researcher, Shireen K, who introduced me to a concept she has termed Mirror-tocracy.

The more I reflected upon the idea, the more convinced I became that it describes a phenomenon present not only within education, but throughout traditional Budō, business, politics, and indeed almost every human organisation.
Why do successful organisations so often lose their vitality?
Why do institutions that once embodied innovation gradually become resistant to change?
Why do martial arts schools, businesses and even universities become intellectually stagnant despite being populated by capable and committed individuals?
The answer, I would argue, is rarely a shortage of talent. More often, organisations become increasingly adept at reproducing themselves.

Beyond Meritocracy: Mirror-tocracy should not be confused with meritocracy.
The latter, famously coined by Michael Young in The Rise of the Meritocracy (1958), was intended not as a celebration of achievement but as a cautionary tale. Young warned that societies believing themselves entirely meritocratic eventually confuse success with virtue and failure with personal deficiency. More recently, Michael Sandel has argued that such thinking breeds both arrogance amongst those who succeed and resentment amongst those who do not.
Mirror-tocracy addresses a rather different question.
It asks not whether organisations reward merit, but rather how organisations define merit in the first place.

The distinction is critical.

Most organisations sincerely believe they appoint the best candidate. Yet "best" is seldom an objective category. It is interpreted through existing organisational cultures, established assumptions and inherited expectations. Consequently, institutions often reward individuals who appear competent not merely because they possess ability, but because they affirm what those already in positions of authority recognise as competence.
The mirror becomes the measure.

Shared Values are Essential. Shared Perspectives are Dangerous. At this point, an important distinction must be made.
Healthy organisations absolutely require shared values.
  • Integrity.
  • Compassion.
  • Professionalism.
  • Respect.
  • Commitment to the flourishing of others.
Without such principles, institutions rapidly descend into fragmentation.
What organisations do not require is intellectual or cultural uniformity.
Indeed, one might argue they require precisely the opposite.
Shared values should never be confused with shared perspectives.
An organisation whose members possess identical assumptions, educational experiences, professional trajectories and ways of interpreting problems may enjoy short-term harmony. Over time, however, that harmony frequently becomes intellectual homogeneity.
Innovation quietly gives way to repetition.

The Mirror and the Window. Social psychology has long recognised aspects of this phenomenon.
Irving Janis described the dangers of Groupthink, whereby cohesive groups gradually lose their capacity for critical judgement. Chris Argyris distinguished between organisations capable of double-loop learning—those prepared to question their own governing assumptions—and those confined to single-loop learning, correcting mistakes whilst leaving underlying beliefs untouched. Edgar Schein demonstrated how organisational cultures perpetuate themselves by teaching newcomers not simply what to do, but how to think.

From a sociological perspective, Pierre Bourdieu argued that institutions continually reproduce familiar forms of cultural capital. Michel Foucault, meanwhile, reminds us that every institution establishes a regime of truth—a system through which authority, legitimacy and expertise become defined and normalised.

Mirror-tocracy sits comfortably alongside these ideas.

It describes the subtle process by which organisations cease looking through windows and begin looking into mirrors.
They no longer seek new ways of seeing.
They seek reassurance that their existing ways of seeing remain correct.

Lessons from Nature: The paradox becomes clearer when viewed through the lens of complexity theory.

Healthy ecosystems depend not upon uniformity but upon diversity. Monocultures may appear efficient for a time, yet they remain uniquely vulnerable to disease, environmental change and systemic failure. Biodiversity, by contrast, creates resilience because different organisms respond differently to changing conditions.
Human organisations are remarkably similar.
  • Schools.
  • Universities.
  • Businesses.
  • Martial arts organisations.
All are adaptive systems.
Their long-term health depends not simply upon stability but upon continual adaptation. Such adaptation requires difference—not difference of purpose, but difference of perspective.
The healthiest organisations therefore maintain a stable moral centre whilst encouraging intellectual diversity around it.

Mirror-tocracy in Education: Having spent more than three decades working within schools across several educational systems, I have become increasingly convinced that Mirror-tocracy presents one of the most significant yet least discussed challenges facing educational leadership.
  • Interview panels frequently seek applicants who will fit the school.
  • Senior leadership teams understandably value collegiality.
  • Departments often celebrate consensus.
None of these aspirations is inherently problematic.
The difficulty arises when "fit" quietly becomes synonymous with familiarity.
  • Who, then, challenges long-established assumptions?
  • Who asks whether assessment practices genuinely serve learners?
  • Who questions curriculum design?
  • Who introduces perspectives shaped by different educational systems, disciplines or cultures?
Schools exist to prepare young people for an uncertain future, not to reproduce the certainties of the past. Yet educational institutions themselves often become remarkably conservative in the ways they appoint, promote and reward staff.

Within the Irish educational context, where relationships, collegiality and shared ethos rightly occupy an important place, there is perhaps an even greater responsibility to distinguish between cultural alignment and intellectual conformity. The strongest schools I have encountered possess a common moral purpose whilst welcoming colleagues who challenge prevailing assumptions respectfully and thoughtfully.

Educational excellence depends not upon perpetual agreement but upon perpetual learning.

Mirror-tocracy in Traditional Budō
Traditional Budō presents an equally compelling case.
Every martial tradition speaks of preserving its heritage.
Few ask how that heritage was created.
History demonstrates that no martial tradition survived by remaining static. Every generation interpreted inherited knowledge, responded to changing social conditions and renegotiated what deserved preservation.

Ironically, many contemporary organisations now reward preservation more readily than thoughtful adaptation.
  • Technical excellence remains essential.
  • Character remains indispensable.
Yet organisations frequently promote those whose interpretations most closely resemble existing leadership.

Historical research becomes uncomfortable because it challenges accepted narratives.
  • Different pedagogies appear threatening because they question familiar methods.
  • Alternative perspectives are tolerated only so long as they do not disturb institutional equilibrium.
  • The consequence is subtle.
  • The organisation survives.
The tradition slowly loses its capacity to evolve.

Looking Beyond the Mirror: Mirror-tocracy is not an argument for appointing contrarians simply for the sake of disagreement.
Nor is it a rejection of organisational culture.
Rather, it asks leaders to distinguish carefully between those who share their values and those who merely share their views.
The former strengthens an organisation.
The latter merely reproduces it.

Perhaps the first responsibility of leadership is therefore not to ask,
"Who is the best candidate?"
but rather,
"Best according to whose assumptions?"

The healthiest organisations are those willing to appoint individuals who occasionally make them intellectually uncomfortable—not because they undermine the institution's values, but because they broaden its horizons.

History suggests that organisations rarely fail because they lack talented people.
Far more often, they fail because they become so captivated by their own reflection that they cease noticing the possibilities waiting beyond the mirror.

Perhaps, then, the true test of leadership is not whether we recognise ourselves in those we appoint.

It is whether we possess the confidence and humility to recognise excellence when it arrives wearing an unfamiliar face.
​

本稿では、友人で教育研究者のShireenが提唱した概念「Mirror-tocracy(ミラー・トクラシー)」を紹介する。これは、組織が能力そのものよりも、既存のリーダーや組織文化と価値観・思考様式・行動様式が似た人材を無意識に採用・昇進・評価する傾向を指す。問題は「価値観の共有」ではなく、「視点の均質化」にある。組織は倫理的価値を共有しつつも、多様な視点を積極的に受け入れなければ、学習・革新・適応する力を失ってしまう。教育、とりわけアイルランドの学校教育や伝統武道を例に、真のリーダーシップとは、自分を映す「鏡」を求めるのではなく、新たな可能性を示す「窓」を迎え入れる勇気にあることを論じる。

The Archaeology of Tradition: Reading Asian Martial Arts Through Foucault

13/7/2026

 
Picture
Text Under Review:
Na
, Y. (2016). The Future and Prospect of Asian Traditional Martial Arts. Revised paper presented at the Korean Alliance of Martial Arts International Conference.

Introduction

Some papers answer questions.
Others raise better ones.

Na Young-il's The Future and Prospect of Asian Traditional Martial Arts belongs firmly to the latter category. Ostensibly, it is a discussion concerning the future of Asian martial arts within an increasingly globalised and sporting world. Yet as I progressed through the paper, I found myself increasingly interested in the assumptions on which its conclusions appeared to rest than in the conclusions themselves.

Like many scholars writing within martial arts studies, Na repeatedly invokes concepts such as tradition, heritage, legitimacy and preservation. These terms appear throughout the paper as though their meanings were both stable and historically self-evident. It is precisely this apparent obviousness that captured my attention.

Rather than reading the paper primarily through Allen Guttmann's sociology of modern sport—the framework Na explicitly adopts—I found myself reading it through a rather different intellectual companion: Michel Foucault.

For Foucault, the task of archaeology is not to determine whether a proposition is true, but to examine the historical conditions that make certain propositions appear self-evidently true. Read in this way, Na's article becomes more than a discussion of Asian martial arts. It becomes an artefact through which contemporary martial arts discourse reveals some of its deepest assumptions.

Summary of the Article
Na's paper is ambitious in scope. It surveys the modernisation of martial arts across Japan, Korea and China, considering the effects of globalisation, legislation, academic institutionalisation and Olympic sport upon traditional systems of practice. Drawing upon Allen Guttmann's seven characteristics of modern sport—secularisation, equality of opportunity, specialisation, rationalisation, bureaucratisation, quantification and the pursuit of records—he argues that Asian martial arts have undergone profound transformation during the twentieth and twenty-first centuries.

The paper identifies four broad mechanisms through which this transformation has occurred: the modernisation of traditional martial arts; their globalisation and glocalisation; their academisation through universities and research; and increasing government legislation intended to preserve or promote them. Na illustrates these developments through examples from Japan, Korea and China, paying particular attention to figures such as Kano Jigoro and institutions including the Dai Nippon Butokukai, the Kodokan and various national martial arts organisations.

The overall argument is clear. Unless Asian martial arts continue to adapt to changing social conditions, they risk either disappearing or being absorbed into broader sporting cultures. Preservation, therefore, requires careful negotiation between continuity and change.
It is a thoughtful paper, rich in historical detail and comparative breadth.

Yet it is not this argument that I found most compelling.

Situating the Paper within the Field
Na's article occupies a recognisable position within contemporary Martial Arts Studies. It draws upon sport sociology, cultural policy and comparative history, whilst engaging familiar debates concerning modernisation, globalisation and the preservation of intangible cultural heritage. In many respects, it reflects a broader scholarly concern that has emerged over the past three decades: namely, how martial traditions might negotiate the pressures of modern sport without relinquishing their distinctive cultural identities.

Here Guttmann provides the principal interpretive framework. Yet there are other intellectual conversations quietly unfolding beneath the paper's surface.

Norbert Elias reminds us that bodily practices are progressively regulated, standardised and civilised over time. Eric Hobsbawm demonstrates that traditions are often less ancient than they appear, functioning instead as selective constructions serving contemporary purposes. Pierre Bourdieu encourages us to view martial practice as the embodiment of cultural dispositions rather than merely technical knowledge.

However, I believe Michel Foucault offers the most provocative lens for approaching Na's work.
For Foucault, archaeology asks a deceptively simple question:
  • How did particular ways of speaking become possible?
  • Not:
  • Are traditional martial arts authentic?
But rather:
  • How did "traditional martial arts" become a meaningful category in the first place?

An Archaeology of Tradition

Throughout the paper, tradition functions as a remarkably stable signifier.
  • Traditional martial arts must be preserved.
  • Traditional martial arts possess legitimacy.
  • Traditional martial arts face threats from modernity.
  • Traditional martial arts require legislation.
Each of these statements appears entirely reasonable.
Indeed, that is precisely the point.

Archaeology begins when apparently obvious truths cease to appear obvious.
One sentence in particular illustrates this remarkably well:
"Teachers of traditional Asian martial arts hold a strong belief that if they cannot maintain the traditionality, the legitimacy which is the basis of their existence certainly weakens."

From a Foucauldian perspective, this statement immediately generates a series of further questions.
  • Whose understanding of tradition?
  • Whose legitimacy?
  • By what authority has this discourse become accepted?
  • Through which institutions is it reproduced?
  • What forms of knowledge are privileged?
  • Which histories are forgotten?
Archaeology reminds us that tradition is not simply inherited.
It is also narrated, categorised, legislated, institutionalised and, ultimately, produced.
The paper therefore tells us rather less about ancient martial practices than it does about the contemporary discourse through which "tradition" itself has become an object requiring preservation.

From Archaeology to Genealogy
If archaeology examines discourse, genealogy examines power.
Here the paper becomes even more intriguing.
Na repeatedly celebrates legislation, university departments, governmental support and academic research as mechanisms for safeguarding martial traditions.
Undoubtedly they are.
Yet they are also mechanisms through which authority is exercised.
  • They determine which practices become recognised.
  • Which lineages become official.
  • Which histories become teachable.
  • Which organisations acquire legitimacy.
The state, therefore, does not simply preserve "traditional martial arts".
It participates in the production of what counts as traditional martial arts in the first place.
This is not intended as criticism of Na's argument.
Rather, it extends it.
Once viewed genealogically, preservation and production cease to be opposites.
They become mutually constitutive.

Critical Reflections
The paper's principal strength lies in its breadth. Few authors attempt such an ambitious comparison across Japan, Korea and China, whilst simultaneously engaging questions of sport, education, legislation and globalisation. For readers unfamiliar with these developments, Na provides a valuable overview of the institutional landscape surrounding Asian martial arts.
At times, however, the paper tends towards description rather than interrogation. Concepts such as tradition, Asian martial arts, and heritage are treated as largely self-evident rather than as historically contingent categories that require critical examination.
Ironically, this is precisely what makes the paper so rewarding.
It becomes not simply an account of martial arts modernisation, but an archaeological site through which the contemporary discourse of tradition becomes visible.

Suggestions for Future Research
Na concludes by calling for continued attention to the future development of Asian martial arts. I would agree, albeit with a slight shift in emphasis.
Rather than asking only how traditions may be preserved, Martial Arts Studies might also ask how traditions become traditions.
  • How do certain practices acquire the authority to speak as authentic representatives of a culture?
  • What institutional, political and educational forces shape these claims?
  • How do governing bodies, universities, museums, UNESCO recognition, national curricula and international federations collectively participate in producing the very traditions they seek to conserve?
These questions, it seems to me, are increasingly central to the discipline's future.

Closing Thoughts
Na set out to examine the future of Asian traditional martial arts.
In doing so, perhaps inadvertently, he also invites us to examine something even more fundamental.

The future of tradition itself.

Foucault once suggested that archaeology is less concerned with recovering origins than with unsettling certainty. Read in this spirit, Na's article challenges us not simply to preserve martial traditions but to interrogate the conditions under which "tradition" has become one of the dominant regimes of truth within martial arts discourse.

Perhaps the most valuable contribution of the paper, therefore, lies not in predicting the future of Asian martial arts, but in encouraging us to ask a more demanding question:
When we speak of "tradition", whose truth are we actually preserving?

日本語要旨 (Yōshi)
​
本稿では、ナ・ヨンイルの「アジア伝統武術の未来と展望」を、ガットマンの近代スポーツ論ではなく、フーコーの考古学と系譜学を通して読み直した。論文は、近代化、グローバル化、大学制度、国家法制を通じて、日中韓の武術がいかに変容してきたかを論じている。しかし、より重要なのは、そこで「伝統」「正統性」「文化遺産」といった語が、あたかも自明で安定した概念であるかのように用いられている点である。
フーコー的考古学は、ある伝統が本物かどうかではなく、そもそも「伝統武術」というカテゴリーが、いつ、どのような条件の下で語り得るものになったのかを問う。さらに系譜学は、その言説を支える権力関係を明らかにする。国家、大学、競技団体、教育制度は、単に伝統を保存するのではなく、何を伝統として認定し、誰に正統性を与えるかを決定している。
したがって本稿の中心的な問いは、武術をいかに保存するかではない。「伝統」を語るとき、私たちは誰の真理を保存しているのか、ということである。

    James M. Hatch

    International Educator who happens to be passionate about Chito Ryu Karate. Born in Ireland, educated in Canada, matured in Japan

    Archives

    October 2026
    September 2026
    August 2026
    July 2026
    June 2026
    May 2026
    April 2026
    March 2026
    February 2026
    January 2026
    December 2025
    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    August 2025
    July 2025
    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    January 2023
    September 2022
    June 2022
    March 2022
    December 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019

    Categories

    All
    Budo History
    International Education
    Japanese Culture
    Random Thoughts

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customisable templates.