|
Musings on Japanese and Ryukyu Budo
|
Sept. 25, 2026Dysgraphia Is Real. But Are We Treating the Symptom Instead of Teaching the Skill?25/9/2026
Writing difficulties, reasonable accommodations, and the uncomfortable question of whether we still teach children how to write. Since returning to Ireland after many years teaching internationally, I have become increasingly interested in what appears to be a significant difficulty with writing among some secondary-school students. The observation is necessarily anecdotal and should be treated as such. Nevertheless, I have encountered students who are articulate, intellectually engaged and capable of sophisticated oral discussion, yet who struggle considerably when required to convert those ideas into sustained written language. Handwriting can be slow or difficult to decipher, spelling remains insecure, sentences lack control, paragraphs struggle for coherence, and extended writing can quickly become an exercise in endurance. Alongside this sits an increasingly visible architecture of support: dysgraphia, dyslexia, difficulties with written expression, assistive technology, additional time, spelling and grammar waivers and other reasonable accommodations. None of this is inherently problematic. Dysgraphia and related specific learning difficulties are real, and reasonable accommodations are an essential part of an inclusive education system. The academic literature also cautions against simplistic assumptions about what dysgraphia is: the term itself is used inconsistently and can encompass difficulties involving transcription, spelling and broader written expression. The question that interests me, therefore, is not whether dysgraphia exists, nor whether students should receive appropriate accommodations. Both propositions are well established. The more difficult question concerns what happens educationally before and after a difficulty is identified. More specifically, how confidently can we distinguish a persistent disorder of written expression from writing skills that remain poorly developed because they have not yet become sufficiently explicit, practised or automatic? Writing Difficulty and the Problem of Explanation This distinction matters because formal written language does not emerge naturally from oral fluency. A child can speak English extremely well and still be a weak writer. Writing requires the coordination of transcription, spelling, vocabulary, syntax, punctuation, organisation, planning, revision and self-monitoring. These processes compete for finite cognitive resources. Where spelling or transcription remains laborious, for example, attention that might otherwise be devoted to argument, organisation or stylistic control is consumed by the mechanics of producing the text. Research on writing development has consequently attached considerable importance to automaticity in lower-order processes while simultaneously emphasising that competent writing requires much more than transcription alone. The literature on specific learning difficulties further complicates the picture. Persistent difficulties in written expression are significant partly because they remain despite appropriate opportunity, teaching and intervention. That qualification deserves attention. A student who continues to experience substantial writing difficulty after sustained, explicit and appropriately targeted intervention presents a different educational profile from a student whose handwriting, spelling, sentence construction or compositional fluency has never been securely developed. In the classroom, however, the two may appear remarkably similar: both may write slowly, avoid extended writing, produce short responses and demonstrate a marked discrepancy between oral and written performance. There is therefore a risk in treating observable difficulty as self-explanatory. To acknowledge this is not to question the legitimacy of diagnosis. Rather, it is to insist upon a distinction that good diagnostic and educational practice itself requires: a learning disorder and a skill deficit are not synonymous, even though they can coexist. Instruction, Automaticity and Written Expression The instructional literature is particularly important here. Meta-analytic research has consistently found positive effects for explicit approaches to writing, including strategy instruction, sentence combining, modelling, goal setting, feedback and structured revision. Graham and Perin’s work on adolescent writing, for example, found substantial benefits associated with strategy instruction and sentence combining, while subsequent research has reinforced the importance of integrating transcription with text generation and self-regulation rather than treating handwriting or spelling as isolated ends in themselves. The implication is not that all writing difficulty can be taught away. It is that writing is a complex learned competence, and therefore persistent difficulty should prompt careful examination of both the learner and the instruction the learner has received. Ireland’s curriculum makes the issue particularly interesting because Junior Cycle English formally presents writing as a developmental process. Students are expected to plan, draft, redraft, edit, learn from models, manipulate sentence and paragraph structures and evaluate their own work. In principle, therefore, the curriculum recognises that writing has to be taught and refined rather than simply produced for assessment. The more difficult question is how consistently these ambitions translate into classroom practice. When a student cannot construct an effective paragraph, has the architecture of paragraphing been made sufficiently explicit? When sentences remain weak, has sentence construction itself been taught? When spelling remains insecure, has it been revisited systematically? When students cannot sustain extended writing, has writing stamina been deliberately developed? These are not trivial questions because assigning writing is not the same as teaching writing. This is where my own thinking has shifted. Initially, I thought the problem might be one of insufficient rigour. I am now less persuaded by that language. Rigour without instruction can amount to little more than repeatedly demanding performances for which the learner has not yet been adequately prepared. The more useful concept is perhaps disciplined instruction: sustained modelling, guided practice, feedback, revision and gradually increasing independence. Accommodation and Remediation The distinction becomes particularly important when reasonable accommodations enter the discussion. Accommodations can be educationally essential. A laptop may remove the physical burden associated with handwriting; speech-to-text may allow a student with significant transcription difficulty to communicate ideas that would otherwise remain inaccessible; additional time may compensate for slower processing or production; and examination waivers may prevent a disability from distorting the assessment of knowledge or interpretation. Yet accommodation and remediation answer different questions. Accommodation asks how a barrier can be reduced so that a learner can access education or assessment. Remediation asks which aspects of the underlying skill can still be strengthened. A student may quite legitimately require both. The presence of a laptop does not eliminate the need to develop sentence structure, organisation or revision. Speech-to-text may reduce the transcription burden without automatically producing coherent prose. Additional examination time provides time; it does not itself develop fluency. This distinction matters because a diagnosis can, unintentionally, become explanatory in a way that closes down further inquiry. “He has dysgraphia”, “she has a writing difficulty” or “he uses a laptop” can gradually shift from descriptions of need into assumptions about what development remains possible. That is where caution is required. A diagnosis should explain a difficulty. It should not determine, in advance, the limits of learning. The Irish Context The Irish examination system makes these questions particularly salient. In 2025, approximately 26 per cent of Junior Cycle and Leaving Certificate candidates received some form of accommodation under the Reasonable Accommodations at the Certificate Examinations scheme, with the spelling and grammar waiver representing the most common accommodation. These figures should not be misrepresented. They do not indicate that one quarter of Irish students has dysgraphia, nor do they provide evidence of widespread overdiagnosis. RACE is a needs-based system covering a much wider range of circumstances. Nevertheless, the scale of accommodation creates a legitimate educational question. If difficulties affecting access to written examinations are sufficiently widespread to require support for such a substantial proportion of candidates, it is reasonable to investigate not only how effectively we accommodate those difficulties but also how effectively we teach and remediate the skills associated with them. Better recognition of disability may explain part of the increase in support, and that development should be welcomed. It does not follow, however, that instructional practice should therefore be excluded from scrutiny. Recent Irish Inspectorate findings concerning Student Support Files sharpen the issue. Inspectors found appropriately individualised and meaningful learning targets in only a minority of the schools examined, with many targets requiring improvement. These findings do not establish that writing difficulties are being inadequately addressed, still less that diagnoses are inappropriate. They do, however, raise a broader question concerning the movement from identification to intervention. A description such as “difficulty with written expression” identifies a problem; it does not itself constitute an educational response. Effective intervention requires considerably greater precision about whether the primary difficulty concerns transcription, spelling, sentence construction, organisation, planning, revision, stamina or some combination of these. Diagnosis, Intervention and Educational Responsibility There is an important counterargument here. Educational systems have historically failed many students with genuine learning difficulties precisely because those difficulties were interpreted as laziness, lack of effort or insufficient determination. Improved identification and accommodation may therefore represent progress rather than pathology. Underdiagnosis remains a serious concern, and any argument that casually equates increased accommodation with diagnostic inflation risks returning to an educational culture in which pupils were simply expected to cope with barriers that their peers did not experience. For that reason, I do not think the available evidence supports the claim that Ireland is experiencing an epidemic of false dysgraphia diagnoses. Nor can current evidence establish that weaknesses in writing instruction are principally responsible for the difficulties teachers encounter. National longitudinal evidence on Irish handwriting, spelling and writing stamina is simply not strong enough to sustain such a conclusion. What the evidence does support is a more restrained, but in some respects more challenging, proposition: identifying a difficulty cannot substitute for analysing how that difficulty developed, what has been taught, what intervention has been attempted, and what aspects of the skill remain capable of improvement. This shifts the argument away from suspicion of diagnosis and towards educational responsibility. A student with genuine dysgraphia may continue to require assistive technology and examination accommodations throughout schooling. That same student may nevertheless become a substantially more effective writer through explicit work on syntax, organisation, spelling, revision or self-regulation. Conversely, a student whose written performance reflects underdeveloped skills rather than a specific learning disorder requires careful instruction before low attainment becomes interpreted as fixed incapacity. The important distinction, therefore, is not between children who deserve support and those who should simply be made to work harder. That is both educationally crude and unsupported by the research. The more useful distinction is between accommodation and instruction, while recognising that the two frequently need to coexist. Perhaps this is ultimately the question that has remained with me since returning to Ireland. Have we become increasingly sophisticated at identifying and accommodating barriers to writing without being equally systematic about teaching the underlying competence? I do not yet know the answer. But it is a question worth asking. A diagnosis should explain something important about a learner. It should open access to appropriate support and, where necessary, accommodation. What it should never do is bring the educational inquiry to an end. Dysgraphia is real. So too is the capacity of teaching to improve writing. An inclusive education system should be capable of holding both ideas at once. ディスグラフィア(書字表出の困難)は実在し、必要な合理的配慮は保障されるべきである。しかし、診断や配慮が、書く力を育てる教育そのものの代わりになってはならない。本稿では、口頭で流暢に話せることと、文章を構成し推敲できることは別の能力であり、書く力には、綴り、文構造、段落構成、計画、修正、書字の自動化など複数の技能が関わることを論じる。特に重要なのは、持続する困難が、十分で適切な指導を受けた後にも残るものなのか、それとも技能が十分に教えられ、練習され、自動化されていないためなのかを慎重に見極めることである。アイルランドでは合理的配慮を受ける受験生が増えているが、それを過剰診断の証拠とみなすことはできない。問うべきなのは、支援や配慮と同じだけ、明示的で継続的な書く力の指導が行われているか、という点である。診断は教育的探究の終点ではなく、より適切な介入の出発点であるべきだ。 Migration is often discussed geographically.
They are rather inadequate questions for human beings. A person who has lived between cultures for decades does not necessarily leave one identity behind and replace it neatly with another. Habits accumulate. Languages occupy different emotional spaces. Ways of greeting, apologising, teaching, disagreeing, eating, waiting and even remaining silent become embedded. Culture eventually ceases to feel like something one consciously performs. It becomes bodily. This is particularly true of budō. Decades of training do not simply leave behind a collection of techniques. They shape posture, expectations, relationships with hierarchy and ideas about effort, patience, responsibility and self-restraint. The dojo travels with you. So does the language. So does memory. An immigration office can withdraw a legal status. It cannot quite revoke these things. But I would be dishonest if I pretended that knowing this made the loss somehow easy. It did not. The pain went considerably deeper than losing a residence card. For almost thirty years, my legal status in Japan had represented something profoundly important to me. It was an official acknowledgement that, although I was not Japanese and could not participate politically in the same way as a citizen, I nevertheless belonged there in a recognised and enduring way.
And suddenly, through the brutal neutrality of a missed deadline, that official connection disappeared. There was no ceremony. No acknowledgement of the decades that preceded it. No distinction between somebody who had lived in Japan for most of an adult lifetime and somebody whose connection had been brief. There was simply a date. I had returned too late. Legally, the answer was finished. Emotionally, it was not. What hurt most was the feeling—irrational perhaps, but real nonetheless—of no longer being wanted.It was clear to me the current government of Japan no longer wanted people like me! Japan had been one of the principal answers to the question Who am I? Now the country itself seemed to be saying, at least bureaucratically: not here, not in the same way anymore. At roughly the same moment I was also selling my house. Those two events became difficult to separate. One removed a legal connection. The other removed a physical one. Together they felt almost like an eviction from a version of myself. And that still hurts. 居場所 — A Place Where One Belongs Japanese has a useful word here: 居場所 (ibasho). It can mean the place where one is, but emotionally it can carry something more: a place where one belongs, where one has a recognised place in the world. Perhaps what I feared I had lost was not simply residence. I feared I had lost my ibasho. That distinction matters because a house and an immigration status are external things, while belonging is partly internal. But knowing that does not remove grief. Indeed, perhaps grief is precisely what happens when internal belonging and external recognition suddenly separate. I still felt Japanese culture moving through my habits and decisions. I still found certain thoughts easier to formulate in Japanese. I still understood myself through decades of experience there. Yet the legal structure that had once mirrored that internal reality no longer did. The two had come apart. And then, while walking through the bamboo groves and tanbo around my former home, I came upon a field of lotus. 蓮 — hasu. A flower rooted in mud, rising through clouded water, opening above it without pretending the mud was never there.
Buddhism begins from an uncomfortable place. 苦 (ku)--dukkha. Life contains suffering, dissatisfaction, instability and loss. This is the starting point of the Four Noble Truths — 四諦 (shitai).
But standing there, the relationship seemed almost painfully obvious. My mud was not theoretical. It was grief. Loss. Dislocation. The end of a legal status I had valued deeply. The sale of a home. And the realisation that one chapter of life had closed without asking whether I was ready. The flower did not make any of that disappear. It merely offered another way to see it. 無常 — Impermanence This is not nihilism. It is 無常 (mujō)—impermanence. Not the claim that nothing matters, but almost the opposite. Things hurt because they matter.
Buddhism does not ask us to pretend otherwise. The problem begins when we require that what we love remain unchanged for it to remain meaningful. That was the part I was struggling with.
“You Must Go On” Perhaps this is where Beckett belongs in the piece. Not as an inspirational slogan. Beckett is much too unsentimental for that. At the end of The Unnamable comes the contradiction: “You must go on, I can’t go on, I’ll go on.” There is something almost Buddhist in that refusal to resolve the contradiction neatly. I cannot go on.
I was not ready to let go. In some ways I am still not. But continuing does not require pretending that the loss was insignificant. It means carrying it differently. The mud remains mud. The lotus does not deny it. Budō and the Practice of Continuing There is something here that also returns me to budō. Martial practice frequently teaches through loss.
The lesson is not indifference. It is continuation.
A Different Kind of Residence I no longer possess the same formal right of residence (evening writing this causes pain) that once meant so much to me. That still hurts deeply. I do not want to tidy that pain away for the sake of a neat Buddhist conclusion.
But perhaps 居場所 cannot ultimately be granted entirely by an institution. Japan remains in my language.
In the landscape I can still see when I close my eyes. The sounds I hear when English is just too jarring...when the oroa of Tokyo fades away on the bike on the Waterdord Greenway... Thirty years of breakfasts, train journeys, dojo evenings, typhoons, humid summers, New Year mornings, arguments, friendships, births, losses and ordinary Tuesdays do not vanish because an immigration category changes. They become sediment. Mud, perhaps. And from that mud something else may yet grow. I cannot go on. I’ll go on. The lotus does not need to forget the mud in order to flower. They are one, indivisible. この夏、私は「故郷」と呼んできた日本に戻った。しかし、その帰国は深い喪失感に覆われていた。 私は日本でほぼ30年を過ごし、家族を築き、子どもたちを育て、仕事をし、武道を学び、日本語で考え、日本の文化の中で自分自身を形づくってきた。日本は単に「住んでいた国」ではなく、私の成人後の人生そのものに深く結びついた場所である。 しかし今回、再入国の期限を約2週間過ぎてしまったことで、それまで長く維持していた在留資格を失った。 法的には単純な手続き上の出来事であったとしても、私にとってその意味はまったく単純ではなかった。 長年、自分が日本社会と正式につながっていることに誇りを感じていた。たとえ選挙権がなくても、その在留資格は「ここに居場所がある」という公的な承認のように感じられていた。 そのため、それを失ったことは、単なるカードや資格の喪失ではなかった。 「もうここには必要とされていないのではないか」という感覚さえ生まれた。 同じ時期に、日本の家も売却した。 法的なつながりと、物理的なつながりがほぼ同時に失われたことで、自分の一部が強制的に終わらされたように感じた。 その痛みは、今も残っている。 日本語には 居場所(いばしょ) という言葉がある。 単に「いる場所」という意味ではなく、「自分がここにいてよい」「ここに自分の場所がある」という感覚を含む言葉でもある。 私が失ったと感じていたのは、在留資格だけではなく、この 居場所 だったのかもしれない。 そんな中、家の近くの竹林や田んぼの間を歩いていた時、蓮の花が咲く場所に出会った。 蓮(はす) は、仏教を象徴する代表的な花である。 根は泥の中にある。 濁った水を通って伸びる。 そして水面の上に、鮮やかで美しい花を咲かせる。 大切なのは、蓮が泥を否定していないということである。 泥がなければ、蓮もない。 仏教の出発点には 苦(く)、すなわち dukkha がある。 人生には苦しみ、不満、喪失、変化がある。 これは 四諦(したい)、すなわち四つの聖なる真理の出発点である。 苦しみがあること。 苦しみには原因があること。 そこから自由になる可能性があること。 そしてそのための道として 八正道(はっしょうどう) が示されること。 蓮そのものが四諦の直接的な象徴というわけではない。 しかし、自分が感じていた喪失と重ねると、その意味は非常に強く感じられた。 泥は消えない。 苦しみも消えない。 それでも、そこから何かが育つ可能性はある。 ここで重要になるのが 無常(むじょう) である。 無常とは、「何も意味がない」ということではない。 むしろ逆である。 物事は大切だからこそ、失われると痛い。 家も、家族も、国も、居場所も、自分の立場も、大切だからこそ、その変化は深く心に響く。 仏教が教えるのは、苦しみを感じないことではない。 変化し続けるものに永遠の安定を求めることの難しさである。 私は日本が自分を形づくったことだけでなく、日本がこれからも同じ形で自分を認め続けてくれることを望んでいた。 そこに執着があった。 そして現実は、それを許さなかった。 ここで思い浮かぶのが、サミュエル・ベケットの『名づけえぬもの』の最後の言葉である。 「進まなければならない。進めない。進もう。」 この言葉は、単純な励ましではない。 「大丈夫だ」「忘れればよい」と言っているのでもない。 進めないほど苦しい。 それでも進む。 その矛盾をそのまま抱える言葉である。 私にとって、それはこの夏の経験にとても近い。 まだ手放せていない。 まだ痛い。 しかし、それでも人生は続く。 武道にも、同じような無常の学びがある。 技は失敗する。 身体は変化する。 師は亡くなる。 道場は閉じる。 組織は変わる。 弟子は去る。 かつてできたことが、できなくなる日も来る。 武道は、ある意味で、無常を身体で学ぶ稽古でもある。 大切なのは、失わないことではない。 失った後も、どう立ち、どう礼をし、どうもう一度始めるかである。 私は以前と同じ形では、日本に「住んでいる人」ではなくなった。 それでも日本は、自分の中に残っている。 言葉の中に。 家族の中に。 習慣の中に。 教育観の中に。 武道の中に。 そして何より、自分がどのように人と関わるかという感覚の中に。 30年近い人生は、在留資格が変わったからといって消えるものではない。 それらは土のように、自分の中に積み重なっている。 泥のように。 そしてその泥から、まだ何かが咲くかもしれない。 進めない。 それでも進もう。 蓮は、花を咲かせるために泥を忘れる必要はない。 |
James M. HatchInternational Educator who happens to be passionate about Chito Ryu Karate. Born in Ireland, educated in Canada, matured in Japan Archives
October 2026
Categories
All
|


RSS Feed